J.C. Higgins/Sears Model 101.40 20g

I had quite a bit of fun working on this single-shot break action 20g shotgun. It is marked as a J.C Higgins Model 101.40, sold by Sears, Roebuck and Co. There is no serial number on it, so I had difficulty finding the exact age. These model 101 shotguns were manufactured by Savage/Stephens from 1908 thru 1962. I'll do more research on dating this gun, and will update this blog if I find additional information. The barrel stamp is "ZU1&", if anyone wants to help.

I found a good website with some information on these guns, https://searsguns.com/jc-higgins-shotguns-guide/ . From that site:
"If you own a shotgun stamped J.C. Higgins, you own a piece of American mail-order history. J.C. Higgins was one of the most popular firearm house brands that Sears sold through its famous catalog for over half a century.
The surprise for most owners is that these were not cheap guns — they were built by respected manufacturers and simply wore the Sears house name. This guide covers the major J.C. Higgins shotgun models, who really made them, and what they are worth today."

This is a beautiful gun, with color case hardened receiver and beech wood. It came to me in fairly rough shape. The stock had a few layers of varnish on it, making it very dark and featureless. There was quite a bit of corrosion on the barrel and receiver, with the receiver being bad enough to have some deep pitting. The trigger pull was very hard, I did not measure it but guess it to be over 10 pounds pull. The hammer would not engage in the full cock notch at all. The ejector moved, but only popped out about 3/16 inch, so ejection was very sluggish with the empty case barely clearing the chamber and falling at my feet. The firing pin protrusion was about 0.015 inches, barely out of the receiver face, and seemed to be stuck in place with very little movement. I knew I had some work to do to get this gun back in operation and safe to fire, a challenge I readily accepted as I really do like working on these older firearms.

First order of business was to completely disassemble the gun and see what I was working with. Fortunately, old guns like this are pretty easy to take apart. I took out every piece, inspecting and wiping down as I went. As expected, most of the issues were from years of accumulated crud and dry oil preventing free movement of parts. Every part was hand cleaned, inspected, and oiled. I went through a bunch of shop towels with this gun, it was messy!
All the parts looked okay except for the hammer and the barrel lugs. On the hammer, it looked like the full cock notch was just worn out, either that of someone had tried to do a trigger job in the past and took too much of the full cock notch depth away. The engagement interface with the sear was a bit rounded with a net negative angle, making this two parts just slip past each other instead of engaging. Hence the inability to cock the hammer.

I sharpened the edge of the sear that engages in the full cock notch, making it very slightly positive. For the hammer, I broke out my diamond knife edge files and deepened the full cock notch, trying to keep it no greater that 0.015 inch deep. I wanted a good positive engagement with the sear that can be felt when pulling the hammer back, a good tactile 'click' when they engage, but did not want to add excessive creep to the trigger or get too deep into the (assumed) case hardening on the parts. More on this later. I was also concerned about reducing the power stroke of the hammer too much, robbing it of enough energy to reliably ignite the primer. If needed, I could always go back and increase engagement of the sear and hammer, but it is very hard to put material back once it is gone. Go slow, and check often, when working on triggers!
A cautionary point I want to highlight here for the reader, especially one that may be wanting to do their own trigger job, is that the trigger interfaces are safety critical. An error or misjudgment in the trigger chain, from the trigger, through the sear to the hammer and to the firing pin, could easily result in property damage, injury, or worse. This gun in particular does not have a manual safety of any sort - if the shooter jars the gun while cocked, and the engagement of the trigger to sear interface or the sear to hammer interface is not correct, the hammer very likely will drop and the gun could fire when you do not want it to. There is an extreme amount of legal and personal liability assumed when one modifies a trigger system. Unless you know what you are doing, do not modify a trigger! Get help from someone who is trained and experienced.

The other issue I found was in the barrel lugs. These soldered lugs contain the ejector system and also interface to the locking block to keep the barrel closed and locked tightly. The interface to the locking block looked very good, the gun is very tight with no perceptible wobble at all when locked. The issue was burrs on the inner surfaces of these lugs were preventing the ejector sear and the ejector from moving freely. Some work with small files got the burrs out and the surfaces polished. Once I confirmed the ejector and ejector sear were moving freely I applied a little cold blue to the white metal areas I had just exposed.

The receiver and the barrel both took quite a bit of wet sanding with steel wool and gun oil to remove all the corrosion. Unfortunately the pitting on the receiver was deeper than the color case hardening, so there are some 'ugly' areas. I do not have the equipment to redo the color case hardening, but I do have some blacksmith fiends that do. If this was a more expensive or collectable gun then I would recommend taking the receiver back to white and going through the color case hardening process to bring back the multi-color finish. However, for this gun, I think the cost would be prohibitive. If the client wants it done, then I will make it happen. Otherwise, I recommend the client keep it clean and oiled, and just enjoy the gun.

The stock needed quite a bit of work. I sanded it and the forearm to remove all the old varnish, and evened out some of the shallower dents and dings. I was surprised to see a 'tiger stripe' look to the wood grain. I chose a stain similar to the original color, and applied many coats of satin gun stock oil finish, rubbing the wood down with OOOO steel wool in between coats. I think the stock and forend turned out very well, with a deep finish that highlights the wood grain of the beech wood.
I then reconditioned all the screws and pins, removing corrosion and squaring the screw slots. Reconditioning and polishing the butt pad was the last step be fore reassembly and test fire.

Reassembly was straight forward. As usual, go slow and check each interface for proper fit as you go. I think this gun turned out very well, I am proud of what it looks like now versus how it looked when received.
I mentioned earlier a concern about filing through the case hardening on the sear and hammer. This interfaces need to be hard and smooth. There is quite a load on these small parts. If those interfaces are not hard then there will be galling in a short amount of time. I was thinking that I would need to reharden these parts. I got lucky, once I finished fitting them I ran a medium grade file across the surfaces that I just exposed. The file skated right across and did not bite. This indicates that the case hardening was deep enough that I did not cut through it, or that the entire part is case hardened throughout. I do not know which it is, I am just glad I did not have to reharden. I will ask the client to bring it back for a free reinspection in a few months to double check. If needed I will clean up the parts and reharden then, but I think it will work just fine.

Once I had the gun reassembled, I did very thorough function checks of the trigger. I cocked the hammer, and banged the butt on the ground, dropped the gun onto my bench (using a pad to not damage it), and subjected it to other jarring impacts to ascertain if the hammer will drop, and if it does drop does it go into the safety notch. As it was, the hammer never dropped through these abuses. This confirms that I have enough engagement that is slightly positive at the sear and hammer interface, and the gun is safe to operate. The hammer drops only when the trigger is pulled.
Test firing at the range went very smoothly. I had no misfires across five rounds, primer dents looked perfect, no leaks around the breech, and ejection was very strong and reliable. However, like so many break action shotguns with hard butt plates, this one kicks like a mule. It definitely lets you know when it is fired.
This old J.C. Higgins is now a pretty little gun that should provide many more decades of service. It was an absolute pleasure to work on this shotgun and restore it to operating condition. I hope I get a chance to do many more projects like this!



Comments